> > > STOP ART-EDITORS WEEK < < <
[september 30th - october 6th]
The beginning week of October will be dedicated to raising awareness about art editing and the results it has on artists and the artist community.
WHY ART EDITING IS BAD:
To give a brief definition, editing art is taking another person’s hard work and tweaking it to please the editor, to make it ‘more interesting’. Artists spend SO much time on their work, making it exactly fit their artistic vision, and when they’re ready to share their work with the world, people think it’s okay to take their hard work, spend two minutes ‘fixing’ it up in photoshop and get credit for it. Because that’s what art editing is— editing another person’s artwork and recieving credit and praise for it. Think about the real artist’s feelings before you even think about editing.
Most editors get their work from pivix, a japanese art website. So with the obvious language difference, editors are unable to ask permission to edit work in the first place. So if you don’t have permission, nor are you able to ask for it, why would you think it’s okay to edit and post another persons art?
Another point is that pixiv artists aren’t dumb. A lot of them know what tumblr is. Hell, even some of them have tumblr blogs. They don’t miss what you’re doing to their work, and that is why a lot of them take down their work and some of them never post their art again, which is a shame to lose great artists over something so stupid.
Think of it like this— say I went downtown to New Orleans, down to the French Quarter where many artists line up on the street to display their art. Now an art editor comes around and takes a painting from one of the vendors and pulls it aside, whipping out their paintbrush and adding their own little details. The vendor watches in horror as the editor places it back, shrugging off the vendor. “It looks better doesn’t it?”
Don’t say it’s not the same thing because it is.
Art you find on the internet does not belong to you. Unless you are the original poster, you have no right to take and edit another person’s work. It does NOT and will NEVER belong to you. Just because it is easier to access on the computer does not mean it is not as valuable as tangible art. What this all boils down to is respect.
SOME COMMON EXCUSES:
‘I can’t draw, this is my way of expressing myself artistically!’
Learn how to draw! Drawing takes time, hard work and practice. And if you’re still not finding that drawing is your thing, and hey, maybe you enjoy editing images! If you really want to edit, try editing official work. This art is made to be mass produced, and the artists are aware of this. Another alternative is stock photos— deviantART, for example, has plenty of stock photos for you to use! That’s what they’re there for!
‘We’re celebrating the artist by making tributes to their work!’
No. You’re butchering their hard work and effort by cropping, adding saturation and uneccesary textures. Ask permission, and if they say yes ( which is very rare ), then you have the green light to do so! Permission is key here.
’But we provide sources!’
That’s not the point. The point is that editing art without permission is wrong and dumb, and it goes against most artist wishes. Crediting them does not suddenly make it a-ok for you to edit their work.
ZEROCHAN IS NEVER A SOURCE.
NEITHER IS WEHEARTIT.
NEITHER IS PHOTOBUCKET. Stop linking art there.
Don’t let editors think that what they are doing is acceptable. Here’s what you can do to help stop this:
1) DON’T REBLOG EDITS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I LITERALLY CANNOT STRESS THIS ENOUGH. If you like the picture, repost it as original with source to actual ARTIST. We need to stop supporting editors.
2) If you know someone who edits, kindly inform them or link them to this post. Speaking up about this is essential. If you don’t let them know what they are doing is terrible, they will NOT stop.
THANK YOU FOR READING and reblog to spread the word!
aw this is cute.
instead of just harassing people individually, let’s start some organized harassment!! :D
no. this isn’t okay and here’s why.
thank & have good day.
I’m really, really, really sick of hearing all the drama about pixiv editors vs. pixiv artists and everyone pointing fingers at everyone else and acting so fucking self-righteous and it’s starting to seriously bug me
I’m gonna attempt to have a say here.
How about if you don’t like pixiv editors, don’t follow them, don’t reblog their edits, and ignore them entirely. If you believe there’s nothing wrong with editing, then keep editing, because if it’s what you believe in, no one’s going to be able to stop you anyway. The truth is, no amount of harassment is going to eradicate all of the pixiv edits/editors from tumblr. The quicker everyone gets this through their heads, the better.
I understand each side to a certain degree. I understand the artists not wanting their work messed with, and I understand the editors are not meaning disrespect and still giving credit and how it really is something that’s been going on too long to just stop altogether. But seriously, those who are harassing, bullying, or chastising editors need to just sit down and realize there’s bigger things in this world to worry about, and you’re making all of the artists look bad with your aggressive methods. It is not your job to police anyone else, and that is not what tumblr is for. Do what you came here to do: blog. Let others run their blogs in peace, the way they wish, just like you’d want others to do for you.
Everyone just calm down, don’t follow someone who will cause you undue emotional distress, and just let this whole situation die, because as it stands, we’re all at an impasse and nobody’s winning. Just. Stop.